A how-to guide to design and develop your intervention protocol
Big picture things to consider:
Develop an event schedule for each arm of your study. For each events these include:
On what day should the event occur?
- At what time should the event start?
- How long should the event window stay open?
- Should the event repeat? If so, how many days, weeks?
- Should there be consequences (i.e. messages, compliance, etc.) based on event outcome?
Things to consider for each event type
- Send a Message
- What day should the message be sent out?
- What time should the message be sent out?
- What is the body of the message?
- How should the message be sent out?
- Text only
- Email only
- Phone call only
- Per participant notification preference
- Is this a one-time message or is it repeating?
- Repeating- by days or weeks? How many times should the message repeat?
- Repeating- by days or weeks? How many times should the message repeat?
- Ask a question via text
- What day should the question be sent out?
- What time should the question be sent out?
- What is the body of the question?
- How long should the participant have to respond to the question?
- What are the valid responses that the participant should send? (e.g. 1, 2, 3)
- What are the automated responses based on the participant's text?
- What message should you send back for a response of 1? 2? 3?
- What message should you send back if the participant sends something other than a requested response (e.g. not 1-3)?
Is this a one-time question or is it repeating?
Repeating- by days or weeks? How many times should the question repeat?
- Administer a survey
- What day should the survey open?
- What time should the survey open?
- What is the message that should be sent to the participant alerting to survey opening?
- How long should the participant have to respond to complete the survey?
- What should happen once the participant completes the survey?
- Message to participant
- Payment
- Should there be a reminder to the participant to complete the survey if they don't fill it out?
- When should the reminders start?
- What time should the reminder be sent?
- What is the body of the reminder message?
- How often should the reminders occur?
- Collect device (scale, pedometer, pill bottle, etc.) data
- What day should the data collection start?
- Should data collection repeat? (Tip! Typically occurs daily)
- Repeating- by days or weeks? How many times should the data collection repeat?
- Should there be goals for the participant to meet?
- Example 1: participant walked more than 7000 steps --> met goal
- Example 2: participant weighed in under target weight --> met goal
- Send a conditional message (a message sent based on a previous action taken by a participant)
- What day should the conditional message be sent out?
- What time should the conditional message be sent out?
- What is the body of the message?
- What previous event is the message looking at to determine what to send?
- Example: Evaluate pedometer data from previous day
- Participant met their step goal yesterday --> send 'Congrats on reaching your step goal!'
- Participant did not meet their step goal yesterday --> send 'Try to meet your goal today!'
- Example: Evaluate pedometer data from previous day
- How should the message be sent out?
- Text only
- Email only
- Phone call only
- Per participant notification preference
- Is this a one-time message or is it repeating?
- Repeating- by days or weeks? How many times should the message repeat?
- Repeating- by days or weeks? How many times should the message repeat?
- Run a lottery
- What day should the lottery start?
- What time should the lottery run?
- What should the lottery look at to determine if the participant is eligible?
- Example: Evaluate if participant met their step goal the day before. If yes --> eligible for winnings, if no --> ineligible for winnings
- What are the price amounts?
- Matching 1 digit?
- Matching 2 digits?
- What messages should be sent out to the participant for the 4 scenarios?
- Tip! Include AMOUNT, YOUR_NUMBER, and WINNING_NUMBER variables to personalize
- Eligible winner
- Eligible loser
- Ineligible winner
- Ineligible loser
- Should the lottery repeat? (Tip! Typically occurs daily)
- Repeating- by days or weeks? How many times should the data lottery run?
- Repeating- by days or weeks? How many times should the data lottery run?
- Apply gamification
- Should the participant gain or lose points for met/ unmet goals?
- Example: daily medication adherence
- add 1 point to point balance for each day that the participant takes their medication
- Should the participant receive a message the next day about their medication adherence? Should the participant be told their running adherence score?
- Example: daily medication adherence
- Should the participant move up or down levels for consistently met/ unmet goals?
- Example: weekly medication adherence
- If participant has 5-7 points at the end of the week, move up a level
- If participant has 0-4 points at the end of the week, move down a level
- Send the participant a message alerting to level
- Example: weekly medication adherence
- Should the point balance reset?
- Example: at the end of the week, set the medication adherence point balance to 0
- Should the participant gain or lose points for met/ unmet goals?
Want an example?! See below!
1-month physical activity study with daily lottery incentive for meeting goal of >10,000 steps and text weekly check ins
- Welcome to study message
- Start: Day 0
- Time: As soon as the participant is started in the arm
- Message:PARTICIPANT, welcome to the Fitbit study! Thank you for enrolling.
- Daily step count from Fitbit
- Start: Day 0
- Time: As soon as the participant is started in the arm
- Length of window: All day
- Repeat: daily- every 1 day, 30 times
- Compliance: If participant walks > 10,000 steps, mark as meeting their goal
- Daily lottery
- Start: Day 1
- Time: 11 am
- Repeat: daily- every 1 day, 30 times
- Feedback: if participant met their step count goal the previous day, then make them eligible for the lottery
- Message:
- eligible winner: You met your step goal yesterday and won AMOUNT in the lottery!
- eligible loser: You met your step goal yesterday, but did not win the lottery this time. Keep up the good work!
- ineligible winner: Had you met your step goal, you would have won AMOUNT in the lottery.
- ineligible loser: Had you met your step goal, you would not have won the lottery this time.
- Exercise tip #1
- Start: Day 3
- Time: 9 am
- Message: Exercise tip #1: Use a buddy system! Find a friend or relative who also wants to establish a healthier lifestyle and keep each other accountable to goals.
- Weekly check in text response
- Start: Day 7
- Time: 10 am
- Message Prompt: Hi PARTICIPANT_FIRSTNAME, do you need help meeting your step goals? Text back yes or no.
- Length of participant response window: 10 am - 11:59 pm
- Repeat: weekly- every 1 week, 4 times
- Message:
- if participant texts back 'no':
- participant: We are glad to hear that you are meeting your step goals! Keep up the great work!
- if participant texts back 'yes':
- participant: Thank you for your response. We will reach out to you for assistance within one business day.
- study team: Participant needs help meeting goals. Reach out for assistance.
- if participant texts back invalid formatted text:
- participant: We didn't understand your response, please text back 'yes' or 'no'.
- if participant texts back 'no':
- Mid point survey
Start: Day 15
Time: 11 am
Message Prompt: Hi PARTICIPANT, please click the following link to complete the mid-point survey! You have until END_DATE to complete the survey. SURVEY_LINK
- Amount of time participant has to complete survey:14 days
Result of Survey Completion: if participant completes the survey, pay out $50
Mid point survey reminder
Start: Day 18
Time: 11 am
- Message: Please rememeber to log into the Fitbit study to complete your mid-point survey!
Repeat: daily- every 2 days, 3 times
Only send reminder to those who haven't completed the survey